artists & participants
The title of the multi-faceted project Where Everything is Yet to Happen (WEIYTH) – starting off in Bosnia-Herzegovina in the framework of SpaPort Biennial 2009/10 – contains references to duration, location and variables of an expected event. These ‘uncertain parameters’ are located between a past that does not offer, in Badiou’s terms, an event to which we would bind ourselves to fidelity, and a future from which one expects precisely that - the “miracle” of event.
Although Bosnia-Herzegovina is the starting point of the project - with its perpetuating state of political 'temporariness' resulting from the still unresolved ethnic tensions and war traumas, the lack of consensus on the basic geopolitical 'constitution' and the unending protectorate of the 'international community’ – it is by no means the only ‘place of expectation’. On the contrary, the project seeks to subvert the view of Bosnia-Herzegovina and the Balkans as the an¬tithetical periphery of Europe, and refuses to exoticise it as a 'space of conflict'. Rather, it establishes it as an originating point of the gaze for reflecting on the urgency to rethink the notions of future, community and co-existence beyond the dominant models of ethnopolitics and of the nation-state, both in ‘transitional’ as well as Western, ‘advanced’ neo-liberal democracies .
The 1st chapter of the project, the exhibition “Can you speak of this? -Yes, I can”, takes its cue from Agamben's essay “On Potentiality' and his referece to Anna Akhmatova's introduction to her poem Requiem, in which she recounts how, while waiting in line in front of the Leningrad jail during the Stalin purges, a woman suddenly asked her if she could „describe this“. To this request to articulate the horror that surrounded them, the poet answered affirmatively. As Agamben notes, “I can” here does not mean a conviction of the posses¬sion of certain capacities that guarantee success in ‘describing’ the indescribable, but a radical acceptance of the experience of potentiality – “[which] is, nevertheless, absolutely demanding”.
By appropriating the question and its explicitly affirmative answer, the first chapter of the project WEIYTH is a way of setting up a stage for potentiality, one where „speech“, but also a refusal to speak can take place - first of all by asking the basic question of what art can, and must, speak about in complex political environments such as BH, specifically the Republic of Srpska, without taking a form of yet another 'post/pre-emergency' biennial.
Answering this question emerges on the basis of curatorial 'complicity' - by the involvement of a group of co-curators the initial starting points of the project were further articulated, accentuated or questioned, and new ones instigated, evolving into a polyphonic structure that opens up space for several points of departure for the future of the project which is itself in constant mode of becoming.
'Can you speak of this? -Yes I can' is an elaboration of some of the themes and moments which have come into being gradually through the multidirectional communication among curators and artists, that reinforced its “diagnostic” and ''analytic'' capacity, forming the exhibition as an initial project the¬saurus comprised of a series of topics and questions related to the issues of complicity, collaboration, politics of language, belonging, culturalization of politics, the potential of non-essentialist forms of community and finally, the audacity of speech as a form of the political.
The exhibition is accompanied by a publication with contributions by the artists, curators and co-curators.
arists: Ziad Antar,Yane Calovski, Libia Castro & Ólafur Ólafsson, Ivan Grubanov, Nicoline van Harskamp (in collaboration with Thijs Gadiot), Dragan Nikolić, Slaven Tolj, Liu Wei, Judi Werthein (proposed by Ivana Bago & Antonia Majača), Florian Schneider, Eyal Weizman (proposed by Anselm Franke); The Archive of Self-Management (proposed by Vít Havránek & Zbyněk Baladrán); Yael Bartana, Danilo Kiš, Artur Żmijewski, Želimir Žilnik (proposed by Ana Janevski); A.C.A.B., Ronen Eidelman, Aydan Murtezaoğlu (proposed by Erden Kosova); Yael Bartana, Esra Ersen, Sharif Waked (proposed by Nina Möntmann); Lutz Becker, Chto Delat/What is to be done? (proposed by Jelena Vesić)
curators: Ivana Bago & Antonia Majača Co-curators: Anselm Franke, Vít Havránek & Zbyněk Baladrán, Ana Janevski, Erden Kosova, Nina Möntmann, Jelena Vesić
SPAPORT BIENNIAL 2009/2010 - Where Everything Is Yet to Happen
1st chapter: “Can you speak of this? -Yes, I can”
kuratoren: Ivana Bago & Antonia Majaca
co-kuratoren: Anselm Franke, Vit Havranek & Zbynek Baladran, Ana Janevski, Erden Kosova, Nina Möntmann, Jelena Vesic
Ziad Antar, Yane Calovski, Castro / Olafsson, Ivan Grubanov, Nicoline van Harskamp / Thijs Gadiot, Dragan Nikolic, Slaven Tolj, Liu Wei, Judi Werthein, Florian Schneider, Eyal Weizman, The Archive of Self-Management , Yael Bartana, Danilo Kis, Artur Zmijewski, Zelimir Zilnik, A.C.A.B. , Ronen Eidelman, Aydan Murtezaoglu, Yael Bartana, Esra Ersen, Sharif Waked, Lutz Becker [Berlin], Chto Delat?